Reviews

We had our sons baptism at Horace & Sylvias in January of 2022, and what a great experience it was. Carl was great to work with in scheduling the event and ensured we were having a great time throughout the entire event. Our number of people decreased due to covid, but it was not a problem at all - it was great to have one less worry ... read more

Christina Lopez via google.com - Jan 9, 2022

Love this place … everyone so friendly,food delicious,prices great … I give it excellent review

Love this place … everyone so friendly,food delicious,prices great … I give it excellent review ... read more

Susan Dyckman via facebook.com - Jan 5, 2022

Food was delish I had seafood over zoodles ... read more

Val Espo via google.com - Jan 2, 2022

Terrific staff!! Food was very good. Worked in restaurants, service is essential, and they were gre

Terrific staff!! Food was very good. Worked in restaurants, service is essential, and they were great.

James Miller via facebook.com - Dec 9, 2021

We have used Horace & Sylvia’s for both of our daughters baptism dinners in 2020 and 2021. Their fo

We have used Horace & Sylvia’s for both of our daughters baptism dinners in 2020 and 2021. Their food is fantastic! We love how friendly the owner and staff are. I highly reccomend this restaurant for private events! Or just to go eat☺️!

Afton McArdle via facebook.com - Dec 7, 2021

This place is fantastic. Had the butternut squash soup it was to die for. Never had a bad meal here. The owner is great and the staff fantastic.

James Marchese via google.com - Dec 4, 2021

Friendly , accommodating staff

Friendly , accommodating staff ... read more

Dianne Rauff via facebook.com - Nov 20, 2021

Good food, great service!

Dawn McEachern via facebook.com - Nov 13, 2021

Had lunch here for the first time today and everything was great!! The food was delicious, and the service was even better. Can’t say enough good things about our server, Dylan, who went above and beyond to cater to us. He was so friendly and kind, and we will definitely be back because of his outstanding service & the wonderful foo ... read more

Danielle Russo via google.com - Nov 12, 2021

Just wanted to say that our server Dylan was the absolute BEST! Its just nice to be catered to the way he did today. Wish there were more like him! Thank you!

Minerva MG via google.com - Oct 29, 2021

Very great spot in Babylon Village. Good food and good drinks. One of the many great eats in all of the village ... read more

Toby Music via google.com - Oct 20, 2021

Lunch was awesome. The waiter was by himself , but was very attentive..

Linda Speranza via google.com - Sep 23, 2021

excellent dinner!our server Emma was wonderful! 😊

excellent dinner! our server Emma was wonderful! 😊 ... read more

Horace Sylvia via facebook.com - Sep 14, 2021

We cannot praise Horace and Sylvia's enough for the great job they did in providing catering for a p

We cannot praise Horace and Sylvia's enough for the great job they did in providing catering for a party for 30 people for us on Labor Day weekend. From our initial contact and conversation with Carl on planning our party we knew we were in good hands. The planning was made very easy. Carl even came by in advance to do a site visit t ... read more

281jaya via tripadvisor.com - Sep 8, 2021

Awesome serviceFood very goodNice menu

Awesome service Food very good Nice menu ... read more

Deirdre Donat via facebook.com - Aug 27, 2021

Great place for lunch. Excellent salads.

Kathy Clark via google.com - Aug 27, 2021

Great night ! Good food & Awesome service!

Maria Margiotta Grudzinski via facebook.com - Aug 18, 2021

First had the tuna on wonton appetizer it was amazing. Dylan our waiter is an amazing waitervabd he always does a great job. I had the raviolis and my wife had the crab cake and southwest salad. Desert was the apple tart. Not one thing was bad. Actually everything was great. If you don't try this place you're missing out.

joe kind via google.com - Aug 16, 2021

Great selection of tap beers! The Carmelicious stout was awesome!Nice appetizer menu too!🍻

Great selection of tap beers! The Carmelicious stout was awesome! Nice appetizer menu too!🍻 ... read more

Terri Alzmann via facebook.com - Aug 14, 2021

Very friendly. Great rotation of beers.

Matthew Gordon via facebook.com - Aug 6, 2021

Had my daughters baptism here 2 weeks ago … not only was the food amazing and they gave you sooo much for an exceptional price … the staff was also amazing and professional especially the manager Carl ! Would have every special event hosted here and would recommend to everyone!! Thanks for making my daughters special day a beautiful ... read more

Joe Toth via google.com - Jul 21, 2021

This place is a hidden gem. The food is of any fine dining restaurant in NY. I have eaten here many times and never disappointed. Tonight Nick bartenteder and Kyle server did an excellent job in making the delicious meals that much more enjoyable. No matter what drink you order Nick aces it. We had rum runners not even on there chart ... read more

William Zaccari via google.com - Jul 20, 2021

Had a 50th Birthday party for my husband! Food and service was amazing!

Bridget Cross-Gerace via facebook.com - Jul 19, 2021

Had a 50th Birthday Party for my Husband, food was awesome, service was amazing!! Highly recommend!

Had a 50th Birthday Party for my Husband, food was awesome, service was amazing!! Highly recommend! The staff and ownership went above and beyond!

bridgetg823 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 19, 2021

Had a 50th Birthday Party for my Husband, food was awesome, service was amazing!! Highly recommend!

Bridget Gerace via google.com - Jul 18, 2021

we loved everything the food was great. Dillion our server was fantastic and made everything that m

we loved everything the food was great. Dillion our server was fantastic and made everything that much better. food was c amazing.

James Marchese via facebook.com - Jul 10, 2021

I came here for the first time with my sister to celebrate my birthday. I have to say that this is such a hidden gem on Long Island, I am surprised that this restaurant does not get more publicity. The food was absolutely delectable! As a season chef, I was delighted to experience their maple mayo which pares great with their swee ... read more

June Stoyer via google.com - Jul 9, 2021

Great food, was quiet on Sunday night. Varied menu. Red sangria was off for some reason but waiter took care of getting us new drinks.

Nicholas R via google.com - Jun 16, 2021

Nice lunch, I had the ahi tuna sandwich which was tasty, good beer selection, server Dylan was good, owner popped his head in and checked on service. There are dozens of places in Babylon, I'll go back, this place is nice.

Dew Maur via google.com - Jun 15, 2021

I was in Babylon scouting for future tour options and let me just tell you I found my new favorite restaurant! Horace and Sylvias is that perfect local place that welcomes you in with smiles and warmth. Nick, our bartender, was awesome. He was on top of everything and gave great service. The food... the food was Outstanding! Everyth ... read more

Melissa Farrell via google.com - May 31, 2021

We have been several times recently and always great service from friendly servers. By the way the f

We have been several times recently and always great service from friendly servers. By the way the food is also first class especially the fried Camembert and salads. We will continue to visit this great restaurant. Very good value in my opinion.

Sean D via tripadvisor.com - May 27, 2021

Great friendly service, great food. our new favorite place. Check it out.

Steve Swetz via facebook.com - May 13, 2021

Food always good here. Good selection of beers on tap. Ordered an app that took almost 30 minutes to get. Planned on ordering dinner but ran out of time.

Michael Kienle via google.com - May 10, 2021

Excellent place for lunch drinks creative!

Sal Williams via google.com - May 7, 2021

The server and bus boy where really friendly and made the experience very pleasant. The food was good too but the service really stuck out.

Brian Hesselbach via google.com - May 4, 2021

I had a wonderful birthday dinner with my fantastic friends and our server, a wonderful brunette, w

I had a wonderful birthday dinner with my fantastic friends and our server, a wonderful brunette, who made it so much better ... read more

Donna Hickey via facebook.com - Apr 22, 2021

the service was awesome maria our hostess was welcoming freindly and catered to our every need chec

the service was awesome maria our hostess was welcoming freindly and catered to our every need checked up on me and my party attentively.would definitely recommend this establishment to everyone.the kung Po calamari was fantastic as well as the skirt steak was delicious.

Lyle E Caul via facebook.com - Apr 4, 2021

Excellent food, very reasonably priced, wonderful atmosphere. Only negative is getting a parking space :) I've been here over a dozen times with my fiance and I will continue to go, it's just everything I enjoy about a restaurant.

_ Kikinak via google.com - Apr 3, 2021

Thursday's prix fix dinners are fabulous. Generous portions. Good quality. Innovative cooking style enhances the dining experience. Wait staff attentive and engaging.

Marie Scardamaglia via google.com - Mar 28, 2021

Nice and cozy FRIENDLY PEOPLE They practice safely serving food.

Helen Binihakis via google.com - Mar 16, 2021

Good atmosphere, loved the Fire place...Personal Pizza's and Chicken Taco's were Very tasty! I'll definitely go back when I'm in the area!

Mary Wissing via google.com - Mar 7, 2021

Just an fantastic please and our bartender Maria was fantastic

Just an fantastic please and our bartender Maria was fantastic ... read more

Mary Danz Rogers via facebook.com - Mar 5, 2021

great food!! Great service. will return!!

Deborah Marks-Berkman via facebook.com - Mar 5, 2021

Service was great ! Food was delicious ! Drinks kept flowing ! Portions were perfect ! I highly rec

Service was great ! Food was delicious ! Drinks kept flowing ! Portions were perfect ! I highly recommend Nick as a waiter very sweet and courteous . Thank You Carl we will be back.

Joan Marie Haupt-Larock via facebook.com - Feb 21, 2021

My experience there was very good. The food was delicious and the menu was troubling because I had such a hard decision to make. The service was great and the food came out at the appropriate times. I will come back to try several more food items, especially the items on the special menu which made choosing my meal even harder. The t ... read more

Mark Buonagura via google.com - Feb 21, 2021

The food is amazing and the staff goes above and beyond to make sure you have a good night! The price and menu for catering is phenomenal and the restaurant is clean and COVID friendly. It's a must try! The biscuits and honey butter alone make the trip worth it but you'll be dying to try everything once you see the menu.

Krystin Phelan via google.com - Feb 17, 2021

People & food are terrific. It's a cozy place from young to older crowd.

Sylvain Chouen via google.com - Feb 14, 2021

This place is the best. Had lunch there today with my wife. Carl (management) and Maria (our server) went above and beyond to ensure we had a terrific meal. Neighborhood gems like Horace and Sylvia's cannot be ignored. They need our support to ensure they are there for us to enjoy in the long haul. Highly recommended!

John Consoli via google.com - Feb 11, 2021

Delicious Endive, Beet & Spinach Salad!!!

Gloria Thomsen-Papaleo via google.com - Jan 30, 2021

Good food help was great. Thankyou Charlie. Great waiter and very helpful

Good food help was great. Thankyou Charlie. Great waiter and very helpful ... read more

Angelina Pagnillo via facebook.com - Jan 26, 2021

Service was great and the food was even better!!!!

Ronni Lee via google.com - Jan 14, 2021

Excellent ... read more

Rudranauth Ramroop via google.com - Jan 14, 2021

Service and food were great.

Michael Cafaro via google.com - Jan 10, 2021

we were sat down by the hostess, we waited about 15mins (the place wasn't that busy) at this point i asked the bus boy to see if he can get us our waiter. finally the waitress came over took our drink order, and then came back with drinks and took food order. i got the lobster meat and shrimp over zucchini noodles, excellent. the fla ... read more

Renee Josie via google.com - Jan 10, 2021

Excellent choice ... read more

Steven Calder via google.com - Jan 6, 2021

Carl is the host with the most!

Stephen E. Yusko via facebook.com - Dec 19, 2020

Absolutely love this place

We eat here as often as possible. The food is consistency delicious and the staff is great. This place is excellent for a great meal or even a catered party.

willevers07 via tripadvisor.com - Dec 8, 2020

Had a great lunch, they have a wonderful menu and wide selection of drinks and taps. Will go back soon.

william bradley via google.com - Nov 29, 2020

This place is absolutely fabulous and the food was excellent...Wait staff was awesome ... read more

OWEN BLAIR via google.com - Nov 28, 2020

Scallops with wild mushroom risotto and asparagus. Yummy!

Geri Gitter Bearden via facebook.com - Nov 10, 2020

Bartender got our drinks wrong 3 time and food came out with apps and some people were done when others food and apps came out ... read more

cutey UwU via google.com - Nov 7, 2020

Great service , cleanliness , ambiance & the food is delicious

Great service , cleanliness , ambiance & the food is delicious ... read more

Marian Hug via facebook.com - Nov 1, 2020

Great food, especially the mussels. Best Chardonnay around. Fun atmosphere. We go there all the time.

maureen galasso via google.com - Oct 31, 2020

food is large portions and delish

food is large portions and delish ... read more

Moe Cav via facebook.com - Oct 27, 2020

Delicious Smokestack Hamburger & sweet potato fries. Excellent service!

Gloria Thomsen-Papaleo via google.com - Oct 11, 2020

Wonderful staff and the food is excellent.

K M via google.com - Oct 9, 2020

Delicious food and great staff.

Karen Scribner via facebook.com - Sep 30, 2020

Delicious food and friendly staff!

Arlene Toto via google.com - Sep 12, 2020

Brought my family here who was visiting from out of state on Friday night of Labor Day weekend. We took a chance with no reservation and the hostess and manager were incredibly kind in getting us a table right away. Food was spectacular! Amazing options for all dietary preferences and large, very yummy portions. Food and drinks were ... read more

Jaclyn Mastrocinque via google.com - Sep 7, 2020

Delicious, clean and hospitality wad top notch, Thanks, Charlie!

Charles Nolan via google.com - Sep 7, 2020

Service super slow, restaurant half filled and drinks were bleh.

Laurie Brady via google.com - Aug 28, 2020

Always great food and drinks!!

Rich Poole via facebook.com - Aug 24, 2020

Amazing food and service! They even have baked brie! Yummm

Amazing food and service! They even have baked brie! Yummm ... read more

Loren Molloy via facebook.com - Aug 20, 2020

This spot is worth trying. They serve big portions for affordable rates. Constantly well organized and with fantastic character. Highly recommended.

Peter Bates via google.com - Aug 17, 2020

Really nice little bar and restaurant in Babylon Village. Amazing food in large portions, over 20 craft beer on tap and fantastic staff ... read more

Vinyl Plane via google.com - Aug 5, 2020

Absolutely delicious and amazing service every time!!!

Jeanine Hamer Borst via facebook.com - Jul 17, 2020

Great and delightful food, I love the ambience the place has, and the cashiers were very friendly. I will definitely eat here again.

Paul Raff via google.com - Jul 15, 2020

The food is delicious but, most importantly, the customer service is outstanding. They go above and beyond and I cannot recommend them enough!!

Allison Landmesser via google.com - Jul 9, 2020

My family and I went here to celebrate my mom's birthday. The staff was extremely nice and super accommodating with our large party. The food was incredible and our waitress Renee was amazing. She even came out with a brownie sundae topped with a candle for my mom without anyone asking. A half hour after we left my dad was already ta ... read more

Allison R via google.com - Jun 29, 2020

Great time as always at Horace. Picked up delicious food and had great Rum Italian Ices! Always d

Great time as always at Horace. Picked up delicious food and had great Rum Italian Ices! Always delicious!

Lena DeGaetano Montes via facebook.com - Jun 14, 2020

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Follow Us